How to Sell Stuff on Marketplace


Welcome to Snafu, a newsletter about authentic influence in a chaotic world.

I recently sold a palm tree from my front yard on Craigslist. Since then, I've become obsessed with selling stuff online.

Here's how to sell used stuff from around your house on Marketplace and Craigslist, and why you should.

If you're enjoying Snafu, it would mean the world to me if you would share it!

Was it sent to you? Subscribe here.


How to Sell Stuff on Marketplace

In the last few months I’ve made $3000 selling things that were already around my house on Craigslist and Marketplace. These are random things that I acquired for one reason or another over the years, and don’t use anymore.

I currently have 20 items for sale, including:

  • A beautiful 8-person dining or office table
  • A never-used Yamaha keyboard
  • A $1300 built-in microwave that my neighbor was giving away

Everybody has too much stuff

I’ve now lived in my new home for about 12 months.

Over the preceding 10 years, I've lived in about 10 different places and traveled with an infrared sauna, a rogue rack, a king-size bed, and a few thousand books. In short, it's a lot to move.

I have a lot of stuff, not because I'm a hoarder, but because I've accumulated things that I love and use over the years. I’ve also accumulated things that I no longer need.

I’m not alone in this. My parents have been asking me for years to help them clean out their house, my wife has an extra bluetooth headset, and I have two dog crates that Riley has long since outgrown.

In the United States, we live in a world of enormous abundance and it behooves us to not have more than we need.

It's a chance to practice selling

I think the turning point with selling things online came for me when I sold an in-ground palm tree that was in our front yard, on Craigslist. This tree would have cost me $1000 to have an arborist remove. Instead, somebody paid me $200 to drive to my house, dig up the tree and truck it away.

That was last month. Since then, I’ve sold about $3000 worth of stuff on both Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace, including a 36-inch teleprompter and closet shelf brackets I never returned to Amazon before the return window expired.

Now I’m hooked.

Everything is negotiable

One of the funniest things I have discovered is how wildly negotiable everything about selling used stuff can be. A sewing table that someone gave me for free is someone else’s treasure – months later I still get texts thanking me for selling it to them.

Price is extremely subjective. I'm not going to pay my mortgage selling stuff on the Internet, but I would never have guessed that someone would pay me to dig out the palm tree. I posted it on a lark.

t's a good reminder of how much of reality is negotiable. The idea that "you can't do that" is usually a matter of creative limitation, more than actual reality.

Copywriting is key

One of the most underrated skills in selling is the ability to write great copy. If you can describe something in stunning detail, people will buy it. By contrast, something that is poorly described – even if the product itself is incredible – won't inspire someone to take action. Even as a marketer, I am subject to this and have purchased things that I didn’t plan to because the description was so compelling. Selling stuff online is a chance to practice the skill of writing copy that can move people to action.

Learn to take good pictures

I would be remiss not to include this since Zander Media does visual storytelling.

I’m shocked at how bad most Craigslist and Marketplace photos are. Just like good copy, well-taken photos might earn you an extra 20-50%.

Here's a comprehensive guide about how to take good video and photos with your phone.

Some things to know:

  • Craigslist allows 24 photos per post, but few people take more than one or two.
  • Facebook Marketplace allows 10 photos and a 60-second video, but 95% of marketplace posts don't include a video.

Take great photos, and a video where applicable, and your item will sell.

Everything in its place

Mise en place is a phrase from the restaurant world, which means "everything in its place."

It's practically impossible to have everything in its place when you own too much stuff. I've sold a few things that afterwards I regretted selling, but even that worst-case scenario is better than a situation where your home is full of things you no longer need.

My office is tidier and my home gym is now superb because things are not accumulating in my life unnecessarily.

Less stuff

The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up and David Allen’s Getting Things Done were best-selling books because there is something almost magical about a well-organized life.

Well-organized doesn't have to mean OCD levels of ridiculousness, just that there are fewer items taking up unnecessary space in our lives. Sell a few things. See what happens. I promise you’ll learn a lot along the way.


3 Things I’ve Loved This Week

Tutorial I’m loving

How to do a flip

I had to learn how to do acrobatics without video tutorials or a lot of guidance since I started gymnastics at 19, and before Youtube.

This tutorial teaches a lot of acrobatic basics by breaking them down into their component parts.

It’s a great little tutorial; well done and really effective.

Tool that hasn’t failed me

ZZ LAZYCOTTAGE Cobweb Duster with ExtensionPole

I think everybody should own a duster. I've used through many over the years. Invariably, they work well for a few days and then fall apart once they get covered in dust and cobwebs.

This one doesn't. It holds its shape well, the heads are washable, and eventually you can replace the head with a spare.

Pro tip: clean the cobwebs before power-washing surfaces for the best result! (Here’s my preferred power-washer.)

Documentary I’ve loved

Skywalkers: A Love Story

You probably saw photos of the couple who got engaged at the top of the Empire State Building.

To learn about their backstory, I recommend the 2024 documentary Skywalkers: A Love Story.

The documentary tells the story of their tumultuous relationship and ascent of one of the world's tallest buildings. I like climbing, and have free climbed a few tall buildings and mountains myself, but the movie gave me chills.


Want more?

Attend Responsive Conference

A decade ago, the Responsive manifesto warned that the rate of change was accelerating, and the future would become harder to predict.

That future is here.

Established in 2016, Responsive Conference brings together 275 CHROs, CPOs, founders, and executives for an immersive two-day experience about work.

The conference is built for leaders who want new ideas, tools, and a community that understands what it's actually like to lead amidst uncertainty.

Hire Zander Media

Every company has a story. Most struggle to tell it clearly.

Zander Media is the strategy-first production company that closes that gap.

If your story deserves to be heard, let's make sure it is.

www.zandermedia.com

Until next week,
Robin

This newsletter is copyrighted by Responsive LLC. Commissions may be earned from the links above.

2560 Ninth Street Suite 205, Berkeley, CA 94710
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Snafu: authentic influence in a chaotic world

Join 7,500 founders and operators and receive a weekly email about influence. And when you join the newsletter, you'll get a copy of my new book "This Might Work: A Collection of How-Tos!"

Read more from Snafu: authentic influence in a chaotic world

Welcome to Snafu, a newsletter about authentic influence in our chaotic world. Eighteen months ago, I was sure the AI tsunami would wash away our work at Zander Media. Instead we've had our most varied year yet. As AI remakes every industry, the value of real humans talking honestly on camera only grows. Was it sent to you? Subscribe here. Real Humans on Camera Still Matter 18 months ago, I predicted that our work at Zander Media would have evaporated due to the coming AI tsunami. I'm very...

Welcome to Snafu, a newsletter about authentic influence in our chaotic world. AI adoption is a spectrum and it's dangerous to calibrate your urgency off your closest peer or the best in the world. If you're enjoying Snafu, it would mean the world to me if you would share it! Was it sent to you? Subscribe here. The Myth of AI Adoption My wife works for a frontier AI company. She's an engineer, working 80-hour weeks, deep in the weeds of the most advanced AI tools. When I look at her screen,...

Welcome to Snafu, a newsletter about authentic influence in our chaotic world. I've spent the last few years giving entrepreneurs the same advice over and over. I recently distilled it into ten myths about business, persuasion, and building that trip up otherwise capable people. If you're enjoying Snafu, it would mean the world to me if you would share it! Was it sent to you? Subscribe here. 10 Myths of Entrepreneurship I've been spending a lot of time lately with entrepreneurs in the early...